Guide
Natural, organic, vegan and cruelty-free amenity claims explained
Natural, organic, vegan and cruelty-free are popular amenity claims, but none is a single legal standard in most markets, so each needs its own evidence. Substantiation means holding documents that prove the claim is true for that exact product, such as an ingredient calculation, a certification licence or supplier declarations.
By Hemang Jain, Founder, Anadoris
What does substantiation mean?
Substantiation is the evidence that backs a claim. For cosmetics it should exist before the claim is printed, be specific to the product and be held where it can be produced if a regulator, retailer or guest asks. In the EU, cosmetic claims must meet common criteria, including truthfulness and evidential support, and the evidence sits in the product information file.
For a hotel buying a supplier's standard range, the supplier or the Responsible Person usually holds this evidence. For a private label range carrying the hotel's name, the hotel should make sure the evidence exists and can be produced, because guests will read the claim as the hotel's own statement.
How do the four claims compare?
This table compares the four claims, how they are usually defined and what evidence to expect.
| Claim | How it is usually defined | Typical evidence |
|---|---|---|
| Natural | No single legal definition; ISO 16128 gives a method for calculating natural content | Natural-content calculation for the formula, or certification by a recognised scheme |
| Organic | Share of ingredients from certified organic farming; private standards such as COSMOS set rules | Certification licence covering the product, plus organic certificates for ingredients |
| Vegan | No ingredients of animal origin | Supplier declarations for every ingredient, or a vegan certification scheme |
| Cruelty-free | No animal testing of the product or its ingredients, as defined by the scheme | Supplier declarations, or certification under a scheme such as Leaping Bunny |

What does ISO 16128 do?
ISO 16128 provides guidelines on technical definitions and criteria for natural and organic cosmetic ingredients and products. It gives a way to calculate natural, natural-origin, organic and organic-origin content. It is not a certification scheme or a logo, and it does not set a minimum level for using the word 'natural'. A claim based on it should say what was calculated, not just borrow the standard's name.
When does a claim need a certification licence?
If a pack displays a certification logo or name, the product must be certified under that scheme and the brand must hold the right to use the mark. Certification of an ingredient does not certify the finished product, and certification of one product does not cover a sister product with a different formula. Ask for the licence and its product list.
STAY's own certifications are GMP for cosmetics, ISO 9001, ISO 22716 and ISO 14001, which describe how products are made. They are not product claims such as organic or vegan, and they should not be used as such.
What wording problems should you avoid?
- Vague terms such as 'pure', 'clean' or 'chemical-free', which are hard to define or substantiate.
- Implying a whole product is organic when only some ingredients are.
- Claiming cruelty-free in markets where animal testing for cosmetics is already banned, in a way that suggests the product is unusual, which EU guidance treats as misleading.
- Using a certification logo without a licence.
See sustainability claims you can defend for environmental claims.

How should a buyer check these claims?
- Ask which definition or scheme the claim relies on.
- Ask for the evidence for the exact product and fill size.
- Check that ingredient declarations cover every ingredient, including fragrance components.
- Have the Responsible Person or adviser review the wording for each market.
- Re-check after any change to formula or ingredient supplier.
For INCI lists and ingredient information to support your own review, talk to the STAY team.
Questions on this topic
Is there a legal minimum for calling an amenity natural?
Not in most markets. ISO 16128 offers a calculation method, and certification schemes set their own thresholds.
Does vegan mean cruelty-free?
No. Vegan concerns animal-derived ingredients; cruelty-free concerns animal testing. A product can be one without the other.
Can a fragrance be vegan?
Yes, if no fragrance component is of animal origin. Ask for a declaration from the fragrance supplier.
Is cruelty-free relevant in the EU?
The EU bans marketing cosmetics tested on animals for the Regulation's purposes, so a claim should not imply the product is unusual for that reason.
Keep reading
- What documents should you ask an amenity supplier for?
- What is an INCI list and how do you read one?
- Fragrance allergens: what must appear on an amenity label?
- What does a certificate of analysis show for an amenity batch?
- How to stock an Airbnb bathroom
- Hospital and clinic bathroom amenities: what to consider
- Gym locker room amenities: a practical checklist
Looking for supply? See Hotels & resorts, browse the product range or request samples.

