Guide

Microbiological and preservative tests for amenities explained

Microbiological testing checks that a batch of an amenity is within limits for bacteria, yeast and mould and free of specified harmful organisms. A preservative efficacy test, often called a challenge test, is done on the formula to show that its preservative system can control microorganisms introduced during use.

By Hemang Jain, Founder, Anadoris

Why does microbiology matter for amenities?

Most liquid amenities contain water, and water-based products can support microbial growth if they are not properly made and preserved. Contamination can spoil a product, changing its smell, colour or texture, and in some cases can affect users. Hotels add a particular risk: refill packs and dispensers are opened and used over longer periods, sometimes in warm, humid bathrooms.

Two kinds of testing address this. One checks each batch at release. The other checks the formula's ability to protect itself in use.

What is the difference between the two kinds of test?

This table compares batch microbiological testing with preservative efficacy testing.

Batch microbiological testPreservative efficacy (challenge) test
What it checksMicrobial count and absence of specified organisms in a batchWhether the preservative system reduces deliberately added microorganisms over time
When it is doneOn production batches, as part of releaseDuring development, and again after relevant formula or pack changes
Reference standardsLimits often set with reference to ISO 17516; methods such as ISO 21149 for countsOften ISO 11930
Where you see itCertificate of analysisDevelopment or safety documentation, held by the manufacturer or Responsible Person
What it provesThat batch was clean at releaseThe formula can resist contamination during normal use
STAY by Anadoris concept: burgundy tall fluted bottles with gold pumps in a pale marble, elegant canal-view window
Venetian canal suite

Which organisms are usually checked?

Batch tests typically report a total count of aerobic mesophilic microorganisms, covering bacteria, yeasts and moulds, and confirm the absence of specified organisms. The organisms commonly named are Escherichia coli, Pseudomonas aeruginosa, Staphylococcus aureus and Candida albicans. Limits are usually stricter for products used around the eyes, on mucous membranes or for young children.

Are some products low-risk?

Yes. Some products have characteristics that make microbial growth unlikely, such as very low water activity, extreme pH or high alcohol content. ISO 29621 gives guidelines for identifying such microbiologically low-risk products, for which some testing may be reduced. This is a technical judgement for the manufacturer and safety assessor, not something to assume from the product type.

Bar soap is a common example in amenity ranges: its low water content and high pH make it a less hospitable environment for microbes than a water-based lotion. Even so, the decision about how much testing is needed belongs to the manufacturer, supported by data.

How do preservatives fit in?

Preservatives are ingredients that protect a product against microbial growth. Under EU rules, only substances listed in the annex of permitted preservatives may be used as preservatives, within stated conditions, and other markets keep their own lists. A product described as preservative-free still needs to be protected somehow, through formulation, low-risk characteristics or packaging, and the claim needs care; see free-from claims.

STAY by Anadoris hospitality concept: a welcome worth keeping
A welcome worth keeping

What should a buyer ask for?

  1. Microbiological results on the certificate of analysis for each batch, with limits and methods.
  2. Confirmation that a preservative efficacy test was carried out on the formula, and in which pack.
  3. Whether the test covered the way the product is used, for example in open refill dispensers.
  4. Notice before any change of preservative, formula or pack that could affect protection.

Hotels can help by following good refill practice: no topping up, clean reservoirs and sealed refill packs. See refill pack handling. STAY issues a certificate of analysis for each batch on request; ask the team what it reports for the products you buy.

Questions on this topic

Is a challenge test done on every batch?

No. It is a formula-level test done during development and repeated after relevant changes. Batches are tested for microbial limits.

Can refill dispensers cause contamination?

Poor practice, such as topping up or not cleaning reservoirs, raises the risk. Sealed systems and good routines reduce it.

Does preservative-free mean safer?

Not necessarily. Unpreserved water-based products need other protection; the claim alone says nothing about safety.

Which standards are used for microbiological limits?

ISO 17516 is widely used as a reference for limits, with ISO 11930 for preservative efficacy testing.

Keep reading

Ready when you are

Tell us about your space. We will send samples.

CallRequest samples