Guide
How to compare amenity samples from rival suppliers fairly
To compare samples fairly, remove the packaging and brand cues, test every sample under the same conditions, and record scores before discussing them. Most unfair comparisons happen because one sample arrives in nicer packaging or is tested by a different person at a different time.
By Hemang Jain, Founder, Anadoris
Why do sample comparisons go wrong?
Samples from different suppliers rarely arrive on equal terms. One comes in finished packaging, another in a plain lab bottle. One is fresh, another has sat in a warm office. One supplier's account manager is in the room. Each of these tilts the result before anyone has washed their hands.
A fair comparison is not about finding a perfect panel. It is about removing the differences that have nothing to do with the product you will actually receive.
There is also a human bias to watch. People tend to favour the product that smells like the one they already know, and the one introduced most enthusiastically. Neither tells you how guests will react. A structured test protects the decision from the loudest voice in the room, including your own.
Before you begin, write down what a successful sample must do. For example: a fragrance that suits a city business hotel, a body wash that rinses cleanly in hard water, and a lotion that absorbs without stickiness. These criteria become the yardstick for everything that follows.
How do you set up a blind comparison?
- Decant into identical containers. Use plain, matching bottles or jars and label each with a random code, such as a letter and a shape.
- Keep a key. One person who will not score records which code belongs to which supplier and keeps it sealed.
- Match quantity and temperature. Store all samples together, at room temperature, for the same time before testing.
- Randomise the order. Different testers should try samples in a different sequence, so no product always benefits from going first.
- Score alone first. Testers write scores before any group discussion.
Packaging is assessed separately, as its own step, with brand marks covered where possible.
If suppliers send different fill sizes or formats, compare only what is genuinely comparable. A shampoo in a miniature and a shampoo from a dispenser pump will feel different in use because of the dose, not the formula. Where possible, ask every supplier for the same format for the test.

What should each tester assess?
Agree the attributes in advance and keep the list short. This table shows a practical set for liquid toiletries.
| Attribute | How to judge it | Typical question |
|---|---|---|
| Appearance | In the container and on the palm | Is colour and clarity as described? |
| Fragrance in use | Smell during and just after use | Pleasant, appropriate strength, fits the property? |
| Lather or spread | Wash or apply with a fixed amount | Does it lather or spread easily? |
| Rinse and after-feel | Feel of skin or hair after drying | Clean without tightness? Any residue? |
| Dispensing | Pour, squeeze or pump | Controlled flow, no mess? |
| Overall preference | Rank, not score | Which would you be happy for guests to use? |
Who should test, and under what conditions?
Mix people who represent different views: a housekeeping supervisor, a front-office team member who hears guest feedback, a manager who knows the brand standard and, if possible, a few regular guests or staff who are not involved in buying. Avoid testing only with the procurement team.
Test where the product will be used. A bathroom with your water, your lighting and your towels tells you more than a meeting room. If your properties are in different water conditions, test in more than one place, because lather and rinse can change with water hardness.
Give testers a simple, fixed routine: the same amount of product, the same water temperature and the same drying method. Ask them to note first impressions immediately and then again after a short while, because fragrance and skin feel change once the product has dried. A comment box for each sample often captures more than the scores themselves.
How do you make sure the sample matches production?
A sample is only useful if it represents what will be delivered. Ask each supplier to confirm in writing:
- Whether the sample is a laboratory batch or from a production batch.
- That the formula and fragrance are the ones that would be supplied.
- That any change before production will be notified and re-sampled.
Keep a sealed portion of the winning sample as your reference sample. Future deliveries should match it, and it gives you something concrete to point to if they do not.
Ask, too, about the stability of the sample. A product that looks and smells right on arrival should still do so after storage in a warm store cupboard. Suppliers who test stability can describe what conditions they test under and what they check; that answer tells you whether the sample is likely to behave the same in your rooms over its shelf life.

How do you turn scores into a decision?
Unblind the results only after all scores are in. Look first at overall rankings, then at any attribute where one sample was clearly weaker. A sample that ranks second overall but never scores poorly can be a safer choice than one that delights some testers and annoys others.
Combine the sample result with the rest of your evaluation: documents, service, capacity and cost. A sample proves a product can be made well once; the supplier's systems decide whether it will be made well every time.
For the scoring sheet itself, see our existing sample scorecard guide. STAY by Anadoris sends production-representative samples on request through its samples form.
Questions on this topic
Should packaging be part of the blind test?
Assess the liquid blind first, then assess packaging separately. Mixing the two lets attractive packaging hide a weaker product.
How many testers do I need?
Enough to cover different viewpoints, such as housekeeping, front office and management. A small varied group is more useful than a large group of buyers.
What is a reference sample?
A sealed portion of the approved sample kept on file. Later deliveries are compared against it to check they match what you approved.
Keep reading
- Manufacturer, trader or distributor: who should supply your amenities?
- Sourcing hotel amenities from India for properties abroad
- RFI, RFQ or RFP: which request should an amenity buyer send?
- How to run a virtual factory audit of an amenity supplier
- How to stock an Airbnb bathroom
- Hospital and clinic bathroom amenities: what to consider
- Gym locker room amenities: a practical checklist
Looking for supply? See Hotels & resorts, browse the product range or request samples.

