How to approve amenity samples without losing months

Decide before samples arrive

Agree three things in advance: who is on the approval panel, what you are judging, and the date of the decision. A panel of three is enough: the GM or operations lead, the housekeeping head and one person from purchasing or finance. More voices slow the process and rarely improve it.

Write the criteria on one page and give it to the panel and to the supplier. When everyone knows what is being judged, feedback is sharper and revisions are fewer.

Share the timeline with the supplier from the first day. When they know your decision date, they can plan their production and sample dispatch around it, and delays on their side become visible early. Make a short written record of each sample round, including what changed between versions, so that nobody argues later about which version was approved.

Ask for the right samples

Request each product in the actual format you will buy, not a decorative prototype. If the supplier offers a pre-production sample, ask which batch it came from. Request enough for testing in at least three rooms. Note the date of receipt on each box so you can track elapsed time.

Ask also for samples of the outer cartons and any inserts, because these affect storage and unpacking. A beautiful bottle in a carton that crushes in transit is not a good product. Keep the shipping box too; it tells you how the product will arrive.

The four tests

Shower test: use each item for a full wash. Note lather, rinse, skin feel and fragrance after drying.
Handling test: housekeeping opens, fills, stacks and restocks. Can a pump be pressed with wet hands? Does a cap loosen?
Room test: place the set in a room for 48 hours. Smell the bathroom with the door closed.
Stress test: leave a bottle in a warm, humid spot overnight and check labels, leaks and fragrance.

Include different users in the shower test: someone with long hair, someone with sensitive skin, someone who dislikes strong scents. Different bodies raise different issues, and a panel of similar people will miss some of them. Record comments verbatim, since the exact words are often more useful than the score.

Score it, do not argue it

Use a short scorecard with five to seven criteria rated one to five: fragrance, performance, packaging feel, handling, consistency with the approved sample and overall fit. Each panel member scores alone, then you compare. Disagreements are useful; talk through the lowest score first.

Weight the criteria if some matter more. For a hotel group focused on durability, handling may count double. For a boutique hotel, fragrance may. Decide weights before scoring so they are not adjusted to favour a favourite.

Keep the calendar tight

Set a decision date at the start. A reasonable plan: samples arrive, a week of testing, a panel meeting, written feedback to the supplier within two days. If changes are needed, ask for one revision round, not an open loop. When you approve, sign and date a reference sample and keep it in the office. Bulk should match it.

If a sample fails, state clearly whether it is a fixable flaw or a reason to drop the product. A pump that is too stiff can be changed; a fragrance the panel dislikes may need a new direction. Separate the two so the supplier knows what to do.

Close the loop

Give feedback in plain terms, such as 'too sweet', 'pump stiff', 'label peels when wet'. Good suppliers use this. If you are planning a custom range, our bespoke page explains how revisions usually run, and you can request a first set of samples to begin.

File the scorecards, photographs and reference sample together with the date. Months later, when a bulk delivery feels different, you will have a clear record of what you approved, and the conversation with the supplier becomes much easier.

Common delays and how to avoid them

Samples sit in a drawer because nobody owns testing. Name the owner.
Feedback comes in pieces. Collect it into one document.
New people join the panel late and reopen decisions. Fix the panel at the start.
Approval is verbal. Sign the reference sample instead.

Questions on this topic

How many samples should I request?

Enough to test in three or more rooms, plus one set for the reference file.

What if the panel disagrees?

Discuss the lowest-scored criterion first. If it remains unresolved, run a small trial in one floor.

How long should approval take?

Two to four weeks is realistic when the panel is ready and the supplier responds to feedback.

Keep reading

Looking for supply? See Hotels & resorts, browse the product range or request samples.