Guide
Using guest reviews to improve amenities at a small property
To use guest reviews to improve amenities, collect every mention of the bathroom and products in one place, look for repeated themes rather than single comments, and change one thing at a time. Reviews are a free, honest brief from your guests if you read them carefully.
By Hemang Jain, Founder, Anadoris
Why amenity comments matter to small properties
At a small property every review carries weight, and guests often mention the bathroom because it is personal and easy to judge. Comments about products, towels, water pressure and cleanliness tell you what guests noticed. Praise tells you what to protect; complaints tell you where expectations were missed. Silence is information too: if nobody ever mentions the bathroom, it is probably fine but forgettable, which may be exactly right or may be a missed chance to stand out. Our guide to bathroom details guests mention lists the usual themes.
How to collect feedback in one place
- Copy every review sentence that mentions the bathroom, products or towels into a single document or sheet.
- Add comments from your guest book, messages and conversations at check-out.
- Note the room or listing, so you can see whether an issue belongs to one bathroom.
- Tag each comment with a simple theme: scent, quantity, quality, cleanliness, format, missing item.
Doing this every so often, rather than reacting to each review as it arrives, gives you a clearer picture.

Reading what guests really mean
Guests rarely use technical language, so translate what they say into what you can change. This table gives common examples.
| Guest says | Likely meaning | What to check |
|---|---|---|
| The toiletries were cheap | Product felt thin, smelled harsh or looked generic | Formula, fragrance and packaging |
| Ran out of shampoo | Bottles not topped up, or too small for the party | Restocking routine and pack size |
| Lovely smell in the bathroom | Fragrance is working | Keep it consistent across products |
| Hair felt dry or heavy | Shampoo or conditioner does not suit many hair types | Ask for a gentler formula sample |
| Could not tell which was which | Labels unclear, especially in the shower | Label size, wording and contrast |
Patterns, not single comments
One guest disliking a fragrance is a preference. Several guests saying the same thing is a pattern. Act on patterns. A useful rule for a small property is to wait until a theme appears more than once from different guests before changing a product, unless the comment is about safety or cleanliness, which should be checked immediately.
Also separate amenity comments from comments that only look like them. A guest who says the shower was disappointing may mean the water pressure, not the body wash. Read the whole review before deciding which part of the bathroom it is about.
How to reply to amenity comments
- Thank the guest, briefly and sincerely.
- Acknowledge the specific point, without arguing.
- Say what you have checked or changed, if anything.
- Keep it short; future guests read replies too.
A calm, specific reply often reassures future guests more than a perfect review would. Our guide on handling amenity complaints covers conversations in person.

Change one thing at a time
If you change the shampoo, the dispenser and the fragrance together, you will not know which change made the difference. Change one element, give it time across several stays, and watch whether the comments shift. Keep a short log of what changed and when, so you can link later feedback to the right decision.
Tell your team about the change too. Cleaners and hosts hear guest comments that never reach a review site, such as a remark at the door or a note left on the bed. Ask them to pass these on, especially in the first stays after a change, when early reactions are most useful.
When feedback points to a product change
If reviews repeatedly point to the products themselves, ask your supplier for alternatives in the same fragrance so guests keep the scent they like. Test samples in your own bathrooms before switching. STAY by Anadoris offers ready short-stay and hotel ranges, and you can request samples to compare against what you use now.
Questions on this topic
Should I reply to every review that mentions amenities?
Replying to specific comments, positive or negative, shows care. Keep replies short and factual.
What if guests disagree about a fragrance?
Some disagreement is normal. Keep the fragrance unless a clear pattern of dislike appears, and offer a gentle alternative on request.
Can reviews tell me which products to brand?
Yes. Products guests praise repeatedly are good candidates to brand first.
Keep reading
- What are the best bathroom amenities for a boutique hotel?
- What should a B&B provide in guest bathrooms?
- What do Airbnb guests expect to find in the bathroom?
- Dispensers or miniatures for a small property: how to choose
- How to stock an Airbnb bathroom
- Hospital and clinic bathroom amenities: what to consider
- Gym locker room amenities: a practical checklist
Looking for supply? See Hotels & resorts, browse the product range or request samples.

